Free JavaScripts provided
by The JavaScript Source

Melbums: Playing the game while avoiding the shame

Wednesday, December 21, 2005

Playing the game while avoiding the shame

It was one fine day in 2004 that Leible and I decided to take upon ourselves a task that Bochurim have been meaning to do since the dawn of time. That is, to write a Bochur manifesto of sorts- describing and detailing the different behaviour traits, actions, idiosyncracies, EVERYTHING of the many types of Bochurim to be found in the world of Lubavitch.

The approach we took originally was to take a certain topic (eg. mobile phone, farbrengen) and explore it from a Chassidishe Bochur (CB) angle, Dodgy Bochur (DB) angle, and the Wannabe Dodgy Bochur (WDB) angle. This method of analysis proved successful in most areas, but for some topics we found it best to do away with these Bochur distinctions and describe it as a whole.

This is by no means a completed work. It is an ongoing study that grows with our experience and exposure to the outside Yeshiva world.

In an exclusive to the Melbums blog, we will be serialising our book here on a regular basis. We urge you to comment on any corrections, additions or observations you may have. Today, we start off with...

THE TEFFILIN BAG

The Chassidishe Bochur: It's a wonder that there's any room for the Teffilin themselves, given the Ma'amorim, Sichos and Teshuros that are crammed into the tattered bag. Old and faded Lamplighters layer the bottom of the bag, jostling for position with a mini Jewish library. Of course, the design of the Teffilin bags themselves is the classic 770 image, with an optional 'Yechi' embroided on the back.

The Dodgy Bochur: There is a noticeable gap where the Rabbeinu Tam should be, but the DB will tell you that he took it out that he took it out when he went on Mivtzoim. The fact that it has not been returned by Wednesday is insignificant.

A vast array of airline boarding passes peek out from the pristine Chitas and Teffilin bag, a proud catalogue of the many places this intrepid Bochur has visited. Miami, LA, Sydney, Los Vegas; they're all there. The Teffilin repair paint that was put in so eagerly at Bar Mitzvah time, now lies forgotten in the corner, kept company by a similarly-forgotten mirror and tzedokah box.

The Wannabe Dodgy Bochur: Whereas the genuinely DB retains the status quo and let the Chitas, pushke and other accessories lie in their place, the WDB has deliberately removed them. He is sending an unambiguous message to all and sundry that he has no interest in them. In their stead, the WDB has put in beer coasters, bowling scores and entertainment-venue pamphlets, their details and images prominiently displayed. Although unusual, movie ticket stubs can, in extreme cases, complete the picture.

10 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Good job!! I look forward to further installments.

3:55 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

oy shmuyik good 2 see that u finally hav a way 2 show the world ur work of the past 5 years

10:14 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

bloody brilliant

10:54 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

10:54 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

10:54 pm  
Blogger Yossi said...

Since the 1st time i read this probably abt a year ago if not more ive had certain problems with it.1st u guys are generalising way to much.For example i am still yet to meet one "dodgy bochur" who has taken out his rabbeinu tams.And these generalisations dont neccessarily apply to bochurim from different places in the world as we know "dodgy bochurim" from Melbourne are on a very different level to "DB" from lets say Crown Heights.I think u should write an article on the differences between them.

11:14 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yoss, give us some artistic license over here. This is not meant to be factually accurate. Rather, it aims to take pre-existing stereotypes and apply it to different things. If the application goes haywire or isn't correct, then so be it.
Much like the Da Vinci Code, where Brown says that the bare facts (i.e. places, historical references) are true, but the story he builds around it is fiction.

12:16 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

which category does the auther fit into?

2:16 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

5:30 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hairy, why don't you post under your own name and not ask these difficult questions from the comfort of anonymity?

Anyhoo, I think I'll put myself in the same category as the first poster- Wannabe Chassidishe Bochur

5:38 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home